Stick with a tight converter if you are rock crawling, no larger then a 2400. You need a very tight responsive throttle and a looser converter is not what you need.
Your amongst drag racers lol of course they are going to recommend larger cams and stalls.
Also your cam is way to big!!! You should look into something like a 215/215 using the LSL lobes from Comp on a 114+4, keeping the overlap to a minimum will help you a lot also for crawling.
TQ, tight driveline, and good throttle response are king in your build. My choice in a converter would be 1800-2200 range.
2000 GMC Sierra 1500 RCSB 2wd - 454 LSX powered drag truck...